Comments on: Devolver Digital Have Put Regional Restrictions Across Their Entire Library On Nuuvem http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/ What're you buying, stranger? Mon, 16 Nov 2015 00:22:20 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.3.5 By: chris lee http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-504284 Mon, 16 Nov 2015 00:22:20 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-504284 i get most of my games for free ,so no biggie .

]]>
By: Guy Fawkes http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503817 Tue, 24 Mar 2015 13:26:50 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503817 Only true solution to this problem is global communism with a basic income system. This would guarantee same price for everyone. Actually I even think that this current system in digital distribution that starts to remind the phenomenon of zero marginal costs is taking us there eventually. No way free market capitalism will work when everything from manufacturing, transportation goes automated.

]]>
By: Lawtle http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503787 Thu, 12 Mar 2015 22:42:09 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503787 In reply to Dean.

I don’t think it’s protectionism at all. Protectionism is typically defined by State intervention – tariffs, quotas and the like. What we’re talking about here are the rights for private companies to lock their goods to particular markets and choose what to charge in different places. It’s not an obligation to do so, nor is it measured by the state. It’s the company itself who can choose what to charge. In much the same way that, I’m sure, the bookbinder would price its UK branch differently to its Chinese branch.

The difficulty here, it seems to me, isn’t free trade – it’s the intangible nature of the product and the easily accessible nature of the shop. Since it can be purchased online from anywhere in the world, and instantly received anywhere in the world, the physical restrictions that normally allow companies to do this (even in a free trade market) fall away. Which invites the problems that I outlined above.

Now, we could counter that with a protectionist market for intangible goods. But, like you, I think that would be a bad thing. Much better to allow the companies to decide their own price points based on market pressures (more or less. A few prods and pokes are obviously desirable, but by the point that we’re arguing about that then we’ve lost sight of the woods for the trees in this discussion).

But back to your question. Why is it fair for the company to take advantage of international pricing and it isn’t fair for us to do it? Well, one reason is because the company’s money is (theoretically) being pumped back into the local economy whereas our money is (predominantly) heading to the dev back in England/America/wherever. Another is because the company is contracting to a service company rather than an intangible product company, so the impact on the market is different. The other reason is that the people who ultimately suffer the detriment are commercial bodies, as opposed to consumers.

So to sum up: free trade > protectionism. But, within that structure, digital games are a special case that need a little extra consideration.

]]>
By: Dean http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503786 Thu, 12 Mar 2015 17:16:18 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503786 In reply to Lawtle.

Which is fine, in principle. But what then becomes unfair is when it turns out that the QA for the game was done in India, or in your book example, the printing was done in China. Because it’s cheaper, because of the different economies. Why is it fine for the manufacturers to take advantage of regional price differentials to reduce the cost of producing the product, but we’re not allowed to do the same thing when buying it?

Why is okay for printers in the UK to be penalised because they can’t afford to match the prices of China? You’re basically lobbying for protectionism, which is fine, there are sound economic and philosophical arguments for it. But you only want to apply it to one bit – to the final sale to the consumer, and not to the production of the product.

Give me a game that was developed, coded, tested, printed and packaged in a single country (or economic zone) and I’ll happy agree that they’ve the right to charge what they like in different parts of the world.

]]>
By: Rob http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503784 Wed, 11 Mar 2015 20:36:43 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503784 In reply to Deadfolk.

I also used Nuuvem for Cities: Skylines. At the equivalent of £12.48 via paypal, I’d be crazy to pass up that price for a legal copy. I’ve used nuuvem for quite a while now, have found them to be reliable with fast service.

For the first time though, I had to login to my account, then use Hola Unblocker to make it seem as though I was based in Brazil. I was then able to add the product to my basket & pay for it. Once bought, it gives a region-free / worldwide retail key that I added to Steam like any other game key.

For those saying I’m taking unfair advantage of something here… Do you honestly believe the publishers don’t make money on the stuff they sell in Brazil or Russia? Of course they do. They make it enough to make it worthwhile to sell there. That’s why I feel justified in buying in this way. They’re still making money, I’m just not over-paying.

]]>
By: Lawtle http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503777 Wed, 11 Mar 2015 12:14:00 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503777 In reply to foofly.

Unit cost isn’t the guiding star, though.

I work for a company that sells books. Each book costs £12, give or take. But the books sell for considerably more than that because of the work that goes into making them. If we charged £12 per book, we would go under in a day because we couldn’t pay researchers, editors, typesetters and the like.

So you need to look at the total costs for producing the product before determining what each licence should be sold at. Then you look at what the market can bare. And the market can bare different prices in different locations. So why should one bunch of consumers be penalised because their economy is worse off? Or are you suggesting that a company which can’t afford to sell at Brazil prices worldwide should charge UK prices worldwide? Such an action would mean that suddenly a majority of the Brazil sales are lost, meaning that the cost per unit has to go up everywhere else, meaning we get higher prices and Brazillian consumers are just plain out of luck!

]]>
By: Lawtle http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503776 Wed, 11 Mar 2015 12:09:40 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503776 In reply to Rusty.

Obviously a lower price will sell a higher volume. Which is great for both consumers and devs. But I highly doubt that most games will increase their volume to such an extent to make up for the loss of income. Even on its best day, with the best pricing, most games are only going to sell X number of units. I highly doubt that most games will double (for the sake of argument) their sale numbers because the game’s standard price (not sale price) is half of what it would otherwise be!

It’s also worth considering that if all of the games are priced at the lowest national price point, sales will become completely non-existent. If X Inc. are selling their game (that they would have sold at £40) for £20 everywhere, they already need to double their sales in England. If they then drop the price for a sale (and we all know that PC gamers won’t even bother looking at it if the sale is less than 50%), then they (effectively) need to quadruple the sales for that period or lose money.

(I recognise that the numbers are oversimplified, but they make the point well enough).

]]>
By: Pako Asuna http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503775 Wed, 11 Mar 2015 09:48:03 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503775 In reply to Rack.

I think you misjudged me. Let’s say, to put it in perspective, that not all people that follow SavyGamer are from the UK so if you think there is a disparity between US / UK prices let me enlighten you that this disparity is a lot worse for consumers coming from the poorer European countries that are forced to pay as much as booming economies like Germany in almost all cases.

Steam’s EU2 pricing zone has countries such as Bosnia & Herzegovina, Bulgaria, Croatia, Greece, Hungary, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia etc. and in like 99% of the games we pay exactly the same amount as the EU1 zone that has countries like Germany and France. Some of the above countries are not that much richer than Brazil yet they pay a lot more for games. Asking 59,99€ for a new game in Greece, Slovakia, Portugal and the other poorer countries from the EU2 zone is a lot of money. I mean in some cases even UK pricing is better than EU2 pricing.

Nuuvem was a nice alternative for these countries. Now the only alternative are unauthorised resellers or maybe the local retail market (but not always).

So to come to your point I never suggested that I want Russia or Brazil to pay as much as the Germans or the UK. The perfect solution would be Russian prices for everyone everywhere but I can’t see this happening. I am just trying to tell you that at least Russia and Brasil are having fair prices but there are other (poor) countries that are not only stripped from their consumer rights but are paying premium prices too such as the EU2 zone I mentioned earlier and nobody brings this up.

Furthermore you have to understand that fair regional pricing is one thing but lower end price shifting is another. In my previous post I wrote that it’s pretty obvious that the big publishers plan to stop PC Games being devaluated down to dirty cheap prices with regularly sales. They want to gradually change that and they will do it now that they have us all hooked up and going. With the above in mind I said I am willing to shallow this tactic (which has nothing to do with regional pricing, to give you an example a game now goes down to 80% at let’s say 3,99€ but in the future the sale will be maximum 50% at 9,99€, which means the lower end gets shifted from 3,99€ to 9,99€) as long as they give us back some of our consumer rights.

]]>
By: foofly http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503774 Wed, 11 Mar 2015 09:42:35 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503774 In reply to Lawtle.

The units cost the same to make regardless of country. If they can’t afford to launch in Brazil at a standard price then that’s their fault, not the fault of Brazil. Regional lockouts on digital goods are only good to protect the business involved. It’s anti consumer at best.

]]>
By: foofly http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503773 Wed, 11 Mar 2015 09:36:30 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503773 In reply to Rack.

So your saying that international business can and do profit vastly from international price discrepancy but as soon as a private citizen such as my self take advantage of these same (legal) means I’m “abus(ing) regional sales prices”?

]]>
By: Rusty http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503771 Wed, 11 Mar 2015 01:36:04 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503771 In reply to Lawtle.

The thing that you are missing in your discussion is that lower prices give higher volumes of sales.

How many games do people buy and then just don’t end up playing or play very little of?

With higher prices people will pick and choose what they buy much more than they do with cheaper prices resulting in lower sales volumes for the publishers and distributors which may well hit their bottom lines even more than “savy” gamers (see what I did there?! 😉 ) buying their games from cheaper international sources given that the majority of the public will tend to buy from more traditional routes.

]]>
By: Lawtle http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503770 Tue, 10 Mar 2015 22:24:52 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503770 Lewie, question: How does this deal with the fact that different countries have differently strengthed economies? Certainly, EU/US prices should be fairly similar, since the economies are all pretty similar. But what is a fair price in England is not a fair price in Brazil or Russia – the difference in our economies is too strong. This is comparable to one of the big problems with the Euro (although obviously on a very different scale) – you can’t stand two different economies next to each other (e.g. Greece and Germany, or UK and Brazil) and expect to apply a universal rule to both of them (e.g. the value of money or the price charged for a game), notwithstanding the fact that the calculations necessary to reach that conclusion is different in each (i.e. the strength of the economy).

So let’s posit for a moment that, in England, a fair price for a game is £20. The fair price in Brazil, though, is £10 (nb: these numbers are fictional, merely for the point of discussion). That takes into account the general state of the market (average prices and whatnot), the comparative buying power of money, and the necessary price that a studio needs to charge to make up its costs. What should it do, then? Charge £15 worldwide, ripping off those in Brazil and giving a great deal to those in England? Charge £10 everywhere and likely fail to recover their costs, thus going bust? Or charge £20 everywhere and deprive consumers of the fair price in Brazil? Surely the fairest solution is to allow regional pricing – it protects the consumers in the weaker economies and the developer in the stronger economies.

]]>
By: Rack http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503768 Tue, 10 Mar 2015 19:57:28 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503768 In reply to Pako Asuna.

You can hardly complain about your consumer rights being eroded when you’re so flagrantly abusing them. If you want to argue that regional price discrimination between US and UK is unfair you have a reasonable case, but arguing that games shouldn’t be cheaper in Brazil or Russia is patently absurd.

If you abuse regional sales prices for digital media you’ll have it taken away from you. What’s worse though is you’ll have it taken away from Brazil too. When games over there end up costing a significant percentage of a family car you’ll have to accept that it’s your fault.

]]>
By: hairy_yan http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503766 Tue, 10 Mar 2015 17:18:31 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503766 In reply to Pako Asuna.

That’s the problem isn’t it, PC gamers have set their own limits on what they’ll pay for a game for ages. Before Steam it was ‘nowt’ and we were all frantically pirating them. After Steam it was ‘75% off’ and now we balk at spending more than a fiver on a PC game. Given that we get nothing but the means to load and play a game for a finite period (no physical copies) this makes sense. Aren’t we just renting anything that isn’t DRM after all?

But the market expands and contracts. We might be on the edge of a contraction where seemingly contrite games publishers who have spent the last few years making concessions to PC gamers to secure our custom – now that they have more of our confidence – are going to hike up prices until rampant piracy and dodgy resellers force them to start lowering them again.

Until then, I just thank all the gaming gods that we don’t yet have to put up with the PSN store! (Unless we use Origin, of course – 50 quid for Dragon Age Inquisition?!)

]]>
By: Lewie Procter http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503764 Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:29:34 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503764 In reply to Marcos Ávila.

It’s pretty much in line with other discounts from Nuuvem, but I agree that Hotline Miami 2 is a bigger title that most of Devolver’s other games on Nuuvem.

]]>
By: Marcos Ávila http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503763 Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:07:27 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503763 I wonder what pushed them “over the edge” on this decision; maybe it’s that Hotline Miami is such a prestigious launch for an indie title, but the Brazilian Real has been falling strongly in the past few months. Is this Nuuvem deal particularly cheap from Nuuvem, or is it at a price you’d expect them to sell?

]]>
By: Deadfolk http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503762 Tue, 10 Mar 2015 16:05:11 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503762 Paradox have just recently done the same. I got Cities: Skylines from Nuuvem a couple of weeks ago, but now cannot add it to my basket – and the same applies to the Crusader Kings II DLC I tried yesterday.

Hola did the trick, though.

]]>
By: Pako Asuna http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503761 Tue, 10 Mar 2015 15:59:55 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503761 Well it’s not only Devolver that blocked IPs outside SA buying from Nuuvem. In the last month Rockstar, WB Games and Paradox joined the group of 2K, EA, SEGA and others. More and more publishers purchase lock their games there ((some publishers locked newer games only but left older games unlocked but that may change). I guess pretty soon Square Enix and Ubisoft will follow, making Nuuvem an option for just a handful of indies or older games provided you don’t want to risk your security with something like Hola which is not the most secure VPN service out there (it’s fine to trick sites into putting things in your basket but that is where I draw the line, I would never log into any of my accounts with it enabled).

The silly thing is that by locking Nuuvem, people will turn into unauthorised resellers to buy cheaper. Sure Nuuvem had cheap prices but it was a legal distribution channel, which means publishers got their share and the customer bought at awesome prices. Now the customer is forced to buy higher because brazillian / VPN resellers need to make a profit. If anything this change makes the various unauthorised resellers happier because they will increase their profit margins with Nuuvem not being an option for the average gamer. Although the big publishers are trying to scare people away from unauthorised resellers with massive revoking and finger pointing.

Further more, I can understand how sites like Nuuvem are being a threat to good and honest authorised digital resellers like GreenManGaming and we have to see their side of the story too. The whole Nuuvem thing was unfair to them so I guess they have probably lobbied too in order for this thing to be shut off but where will this end… Region locking, gift locking, purchase locking, activation locking, one time non transferable licenses… Where are our consumers rights… We are paying for a service and we own nothing… Absolutely nothing… But I guess that is the result of frequent 75% sales in pc gaming. Publishers now that pc gaming is on the uprise and the console model doesn’t seem to viable and future proof are turning their gaze to pcs and want to increase the value of pc games (which is dirty cheap nowadays) by first locking things down and then gradually doing less aggressive sales. I can related to that provided they give us back our consumer rights.

]]>
By: Lewie Procter http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503760 Tue, 10 Mar 2015 15:38:55 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503760 In reply to Chris.

Yeah you should get your key in the next few hours. It’s not out yet, and sometimes there is a short delay getting keys for preorders from Nuuvem.

]]>
By: Chris http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503759 Tue, 10 Mar 2015 15:37:15 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503759 I bought the special edition of HLM2 from there. When I got the message saying not able to buy in my region I assumed it was Nuuvem itself and always did it. I used Hola to say I was in Brazil and bought it. Last time I checked I hadn’t been given the key. I’m assuming it will come out nearer go live of the game. Right now I cannot access the log in page on Nuuvem to check as I keep getting an error 404.

]]>
By: Thomas Ryan http://savygamer.co.uk/2015/03/10/devolver-digital-have-put-regional-restrictions-across-their-entire-library-on-nuuvem/#comment-503758 Tue, 10 Mar 2015 15:05:27 +0000 http://savygamer.co.uk/?p=65192#comment-503758 I think a great store to buy games from is GoG, mainly because they give back when regional pricing affects a game’s price. Right now, if you pre-purchase Hotline Miami 2 on GoG.com you can get it for £10.89 (10% off), and you also receive another £1.90 towards any future purchase made on the site. Sure, you don’t get a Steam key, but GoG are great to their customers, and they’ll also have a Steam style program soon.

When talking about restricting the sale of games based on region, I think, like you said, that it’s their choice as a company, but it does seem like a strange move. I’m sure we’ll see it in a humble bundle at some point, and many people will probably just wait for that to come around instead of pre-ordering… So they are ultimately shooting themselves in the foot by cutting themselves out of some early sales where they could get more money for their game.

At the end of the day, someone in marketing thought it was a good idea…

]]>